Laws governing appeals to be reviewed by The Law Commission

Published on 26 October 2022
The review follows calls from various bodies to improve the laws relevant to appeals
Brief
3 mins read
Police officer gloves

A review by The Law Commission of England and Wales has been launched to look at the laws governing appeals for criminal cases.

The effectiveness of the current legislation will be scrutinised, as well as any inconsistencies and gaps within the current law.

Some of the areas that will be covered within the review include:

  • the powers of the Court of Appeal
  • whether there is evidence that the ‘safety test’ may make it difficult to correct any miscarriages of justice
  • the test used by the Criminal Case Review Commission
  • the Attorney General’s powers to refer a case to the Court of Appeal because the sentence is ‘unduly lenient’

The appeals system has faced calls for reform in recent years – often marked by conflicting views on the areas of law that should be changed.

Our wide-ranging review of appeals will look at the evidence behind competing arguments for reform. We will closely scrutinise where the law is working well, and where it may be falling short.

Professor Penney Lewis, Law Commissioner for Criminal Law

The next step in the review process will be an initial scoping and pre-consultation engagement with stakeholders.

Read more: Law Commission to undertake review of the appeals system

Was this page useful?

Do not provide personal information such as your name or email address in the feedback form. Read our privacy policy for more information on how we use this data

What is the reason for your answer?
I couldn't find what I was looking for
The information wasn't relevant to me
The information is too complicated
Other